AbstractThe study aimed to analyse data from epizootological monitoring, microbiological and molecular genetic studies to assess the genetic biodiversity of Yersinia pestis (Y. pestis) strains, to determine the effectiveness of using individual methods and to develop the necessary algorithm for evaluating genetic methods and creating a biorepository of natural isolates of these pathogens. As a result, the biodiversity of Y. pestis strains isolated in natural plague foci of Kazakhstan was analysed using classical and modern methods (polymerase chain reaction, Multi Locus Variable Number Tandem Repeat Analysis, VITEK 2 Compact, MiniION Oxford Nanopore, MiSeq sequencer) of research and geographic information system (GIS) technology. Spatial and temporal characteristics of plague infection in the plague-enriched areas of the country were described. The study summarised the characteristics of phenotypic and molecular genetic properties of 1220 Y. pestis strains isolated from different sites in natural plague foci of the country during the period 2010-2023. As a result, 94.8% of Y. pestis strains were typical of these plague foci, and 5.2% of strains had altered properties in some respects. To obtain information on genetic diversity and their geographical distribution, 82 DNA samples of Y. pestis strains were studied. Three phylogenetic trees were constructed, GIS maps were compiled and a gene bank, a biorepository of molecular characteristics was created to obtain specific genetic characteristics of strains and a complete picture of the genetic parameters of the plague pathogen isolated from various sites in natural foci of Kazakhstan.
IntroductionPlague is an infectious disease caused by the bacterium Yersinia pestis (Y. pestis), which causes a public health emergency and is subject to the International Health Regulations (IHR). Historically, plague has caused widespread pandemics with high mortality [1]. Knowledge of fundamental environmental laws can substantially contribute to the study of the natural foci of diseases. The huge epidemic complications caused by the anthropogenic transformation of landscapes raise concerns among the scientific community regarding the expansion of the natural reservoir of the plague microbe in the modern world. The complex ecological system of the natural plague foci consists of a close relationship between the plague microbe with the carrier of infection and the microbe parasitising on the carrier, which ensures the formation of a transmissible way of maintaining the plague enzootic disease [2, 3].
Modern research addresses the epizootological differentiation of the plague foci, considering the biochemical and genetic properties of the plague microbe. Meka-Mechenko et al., [4] substantially contributed to the understanding of the spatial and temporal characteristics of plague foci, particularly through their investigation of the phenotypic and molecular-genetic attributes of Y. pestis strains. This study provided indispensable data regarding the stability and circulation of the plague pathogen in enzootic areas, particularly in desert and semi-desert regions where the microbe’s transmission is most prevalent. Keller et al., [5] additionally investigated the molecular mechanisms of Y. pestis pathogenicity, with a particular emphasis on its virulence factors and their expression in response to diverse environmental conditions. The study described how specific biochemical properties, such as the production of toxins and enzymes, influence the microbe's survival and dissemination.
Furthermore, Venugopal & Pechous [6], and Demeure et al., [7] have made notable contributions to the field of Y. pestis genetics, particularly through the utilisation of full-genome sequencing and phylogenetic analyses. These studies highlighted the significance of genetic polymorphism in the differentiation of plague foci and have provided a foundation for the construction of genetic repositories that map the phylogenetic relationships of Y. pestis strains. Such repositories are vital for the ongoing surveillance of the pathogen and the development of preventative measures against potential future outbreaks.
The study by Dzhaparova et al., [8] and Sariyeva et al., [9] addressed the practical applications of genetic research in the management and control of plague foci. The studies provide guidelines for enhancing the effectiveness of plague monitoring systems, particularly in Kazakhstan, where the natural foci of plague span vast areas. By analysing the genetic and biochemical characteristics of plague strains, the study provided a basis for the creation of biorepositories that store genetic data from various plague isolates, thereby enhancing the ability to predict and prevent future outbreaks.
Significant changes in the environment as a result of anthropogenic influence affected the nature of the spread of the plague microbe strains in the territory of the natural foci and the manifestation of epizootics [10, 11]. The landscapes with limited areas of desert and semi-desert zones are the optimal places for stable circulation of the plague microbe, where the existence and support of the foci activity of abiotic and biotic factors are favourable. Central Asia is one such zone [12].
The natural plague endemic range is in Kazakhstan on an area of 1,117,000 km2, which is 72 approximately 41% of the territory of Kazakhstan. Notably, under the influence of anthropogenic and climatic conditions, the size of the areas of natural plague foci in Kazakhstan increased by 79,710 km2 (9.98%) for the period 1990-2020 [13]. Historically, during the period 1920-2003, more than 2000 people contracted plague in the desert natural plague hotspot zone of Central Asia, of whom 90.6% died, including in Kazakhstan more than 1,000 people contracted plague, of whom 80% died [14]. Registration of human cases of plague infection in Kazakhstan was in 2003.
Preventive services of Kazakhstan annually conduct the necessary scope of sanitary and preventive measures in natural foci of plague, including constant epizootic monitoring with laboratory examination, planned settlement disinsection and deratisation, sanitary and educational work, and in case of detection of epizootic among wild animals – the creation of protective zones by field disinsection around temporary and permanent settlements. The annual scope and timeliness of preventive measures ensure that the risk of infection of humans and camels is reduced, and plague is not spread [15, 16].
The study aims to analyse the results of epidemiological surveys of plague-affected areas of the country and to assess the genetic diversity and spatial and temporal characteristics of Y. pestis strains concerning genetic polymorphism to develop a comprehensive algorithm for plague infection, improve monitoring and create a biorepository of natural isolates of these pathogens circulating in natural plague foci of Kazakhstan.
As such, the biochemical and genetic properties of the plague microbe strain during the epizootological differentiation determine the relevance of the purpose of the study. Such studies contribute to the accumulation of research results obtained when monitoring natural focal infections in enzootic territories that are predisposed to outbreaks of infectious diseases among people and are necessary to improve and increase the effectiveness of preventive measures against the plague.
Materials and MethodsEpizootological monitoringThe established methods were used in epizootological monitoring, the data of which were analysed in the system of geographic information system (GIS) technology using ArcGIS 10.2.2 [17]. The study was conducted at the Central Reference Laboratory of Masgut Aikimbayev National Scientific Centre for Particularly Dangerous Infections of the Ministry of Healthcare of the Republic of Kazakhstan (MH RK). Full genomic DNA sequencing of plague microbe strains was carried out at the laboratory of the National Centre for Biotechnology in Astana, Republic of Kazakhstan. The basis for epizootological monitoring is the Resolution of the Ministry of Health of the Republic of Kazakhstan No. 8 “On Making Amendments and Additions to the Resolution of the Chief State Sanitary Doctor of Kostanay Region No. 5” [18].
In total, for the period 2011-2023, phenotypic and molecular-genetic properties of more than 1220 strains of Y. pestis isolated from 12 autonomous foci of the Central Asian desert and two foci of the Tien Shan high-mountain natural plague foci of Kazakhstan have been analysed. This list does not include the 28 strains of Y. pestis isolated from highland (Sary-Djaz and Talas – 17 strains) and Caspian Depression plague foci (Volga-Ural sandy, Volga-Ural and Ural-Uilsky steppe – 11 strains) used for genotyping.
The materials were based on the accumulated long-term observations in the course of epizootic monitoring within the plague-affected areas of the Republic of Kazakhstan.
Analysis of the properties of strainsThe data from laboratory studies of 1,212 strains and DNA of 82 isolates of Y. pestis isolated from natural plague foci of Kazakhstan were used. All manipulations with strains of Y. pestis strains were conducted following the norms of biological safety and methods of plague pathogen handling [17]. Identification of the plague microbe was done by standard microbiological, biochemical and serological indirect haemagglutination reactions with erythrocyte immunoglobulin diagnostic. To confirm the species properties and sensitivity to antibacterial drugs, an automatic microbiological analyser Vitek 2 Compact 30 (BioMerieux, USA) was used, which is a modern physicochemical method of analysis based on turbidimetry (sensitivity) and colourimetry (identification) with test cards for “VITEK 2 Compact” and software “VITEK®2 Systems 7.01”. The data of molecular-genetic properties of DNA of 225 strains of Y. pestis studied by specialists of Masgut Aikimbayev National Scientific Centre for Particularly Dangerous Infections for the period 2007-2022 were used to construct the graph. DNA of 48 strains and DNA genotyping of 34 strains of Y. pestis were used for full genome sequencing [19, 20]. The isolated DNA samples were obtained from the working collection of the research centre and isolated for the period 1950-2022, and stored at -70°C.
DNA extraction of Y. pestis strains was done by using the QIAamp® DNA Mini Kit (Qiagen, USA) [21, 22]. DNA concentration was measured spectrophotometrically and fluorimetrically using a NanoDrop1000 spectrophotometer and Qubit fluorimeter. Genetic studies of the DNA of Y. pestis strains were carried out using primers complementary to fragments specific for the plague microbe, saf1, pla, and YopE genes. Test systems from different manufacturers were used: “AmpliSens®Y. pestis-FL”, Russia (TU 9398-185-01897593-2011), “GenPest”, Russia (TU-8895-00501898109-2007), GenPak (IsoGen, Russia), Dream Taq PCR Master Mix (“Thermo Scientific”, USA) and experimental series “Pest-Quest” Masgut Aikimbayev National Scientific Centre for Particularly Dangerous Infections, Kazakhstan (KZ (13) a4 (11) 26601).
The Multi Locus Variable Number Tandem Repeat (VNTR) Analysis (MLVA) molecular typing of DNA from 34 Y. pestis strains was performed at 25 VNTR loci. The amplification was performed on a Veriti classical polymerase chain reaction (PCR) thermocycler (Applied Biosystems, USA). The PCR product was analysed by the classical method of gel electrophoresis.
Whole-genome DNA sequencing of 32 Y. pestis strains was performed on a high-throughput sequencer “MiSeq” on the Illumina platform (USA) using a set of chemical reagents “MiSeq® Reagent Kit v3, 600 cycles”, with the catalogue number MS-102-3003, following the manufacturer’s instructions. DNA samples were prepared using a Nextera®XT DNA library kit (FC-131-1024) according to the manufacturer’s instructions. For 16 Y. pestis DNA, a MiniION (Mk1C MIN-101C, Oxford Nanopore England) was used. The sequencing results were entered into a modular tool for combining the results of bioinformatic analysis into a single report of the MultiQC software (Version V 1.12; report created on 11.04.2022, 11:02 a.m. based on the data: /home/lpg/Desktop/Chuma-2/qc).
The DNA libraries EMBL and GenBank, members of the International Nucleotide Sequence Database Collaboration, were used in the study. Phylogenetic analysis and tree construction were performed using PAUP 4.0 software using the unweighted pair group method with the arithmetic mean (UPGMA) algorithm.
Research quality controlReference strains obtained from the depository and working collections of the Museum of Living Cultures of Masgut Aikimbayev National Scientific Centre for Particularly Dangerous Infections, including 17 reference strains of Y. pestis from different plague foci of Kazakhstan, 1 strain of Y. pestis EV, 4 strains of Y. pseudotuberculosis were used for quality control. Strains representing the main biovars of the plague pathogen, Y. pestis, were also used as reference samples: Pestoides F (Microtus/Antiqua biovar), Nepal516 (Antiqua biovar), KIM10+ (Mediaevalis biovar) and CO92 (Orientalis biovar).
ResultsEpidemiological monitoringThere are 6 natural and 15 autonomous foci in the republic, within which more than 90 landscape-epizootological districts are allocated (Figure 1). In Kazakhstan, plague was detected in more than 40 species of rodents, predatory and insectivorous mammals, hares, ungulates, and 2 species of birds. The main carriers of the plague are gerbils, gophers, marmots, and voles. Fleas are the carriers of natural plague foci. The modern fauna of specific flea species in Kazakhstan and Central Asia consists of 48 forms belonging to 9 genera and 6 families: Pulicidae, Hystrichopsyllidae, Coptopsyllidae, Leptopsyllidae, Ceratophyllidae, Ctenophthalmidae. In Kazakhstan, 51 species of fleas spontaneously infected with the plague microbe were recorded.
Each natural focal point of plague in Kazakhstan is autonomous, differing in landscape, spatial and biocenotic structure, types of carriers and vectors, frequency and intensity of epizootics, epidemic and epizootic potentials, as well as the risk of epidemiological complications [12, 13, 23]. In natural plague foci, secondary hosts are essential for Yersinia pestis circulation and persistence during times of low primary host density. When populations of primary hosts decline, these secondary hosts – which could include other mammals or alternative rodent species – serve as reservoirs or transient carriers to help the infection survive. Secondary hosts aid in bridging inter-epizootic periods and support the pathogen's long-term ecological stability by offering more hosts for infection and permitting transmission cycles to continue. Their involvement highlights the significance of monitoring numerous host species in epidemiological surveillance and adds complexity to the dynamics of plague, potentially affecting the timing and severity of outbreaks.
Through the direct or indirect transfer of infectious agents across species borders, interspecific contacts help spread Yersinia pestis throughout various rodent populations. Fleas and other ectoparasites carrying the plague bacterium can transport across hosts, linking disparate populations, when individuals of various rodent species share habitats, burrows, or foraging locations [24, 25]. The disease can spread beyond a single host species and endure across a larger ecological community thanks to these interactions, which also raise the likelihood of cross-species transmission. Such transmission mechanisms prolong enzootic cycles and may raise the danger of epizootics or spillover to humans by ensuring pathogen circulation even in the event of a reduction in one host population, hence enhancing the resilience of plague foci.
The results of the data on spatial and temporal characteristics of epizootics among wild animals and Y. pestis strains circulating in natural foci of plague in Kazakhstan using GIS tools for the period 2010-2023 are illustrated in Figure 2.
The results of epizootological monitoring demonstrated that all natural plague foci are epizootically active and pose a real threat of human infection, except for the steppe plague foci of Kazakhstan. Of all the foci, the Central Asian desert plague centre by its size (83.1%), epidemic manifestations in the past and epizootic activity to date occupies the main position, where there are four nuclei of plague enzootics. In general, during the analysed period (2010-2023) the epizootic process was registered only within the group of desert plague foci virtually continuously (except for two steppe plague foci), but in some autonomous foci seasonality and cyclicity of epizootic processes are sharply expressed. Thanks to a complex of preventive measures, since 2003, no plague morbidity among humans has been observed in Kazakhstan.
Phenotypic propertiesBiochemical properties of Y. pestis do not degrade urea and do not form oxidase, acetylmethylcarbinol, indole and hydrogen sulphide. Produces catalase. Relation to nitrate depends on the origin of the strains and is a diagnostic trait. Exhibits plasma coagulase and fibrinolytic activity (except for Caucasian subspecies strains). Ferments D-glucose, D-maltose, mannitol, D-galactose, D-mannose, D-levulose, and esculin to acid without gas. Does not ferment lactose, sucrose, cellobiose, inositol, dulcite, sorbitol. The relation to glycerol, rhamnose, arabinose, and melibiose is a variable, of diagnostic value. Gelatin does not liquefy.
The study of basic biochemical properties of Y. pestis strains was conducted based on the activity of the epizootic process, the peculiarities of biocenotic and spatial structures the registration of plague cases among humans and the risk of epidemiological complications using long-term data. Considering the above criteria, strains were divided into two groups: group 1 – strains from plague foci with high epidemic activity and frequent human plague and epidemic complications, and group 2 – strains from plague foci with high epidemic activity and rare (or no) human plague and epidemic complications (Table 1).
The vast majority of Y. pestis strains studied were typical of Central Asian Southern Desert populations of Kazakhstan in terms of culture and morphological, biochemical and enzymatic characteristics. All strains fermented glycerol, glucose, manitol, maltose, and arabinose and did not cleave rhamnose; they were pesticinogenic and had no denitrifying ability. Most strains produced fraction 1 (F1) and were highly virulent to laboratory animals: LD50 for guinea pigs 1×106 m.с., for white mice LD50 1.6-9×104 m.с. All strains of the plague microbe were sensitive to antibacterial drugs. No antibiotic-resistant and phage-resistant strains were detected.
The results of laboratory studies on phenotypic characteristics showed that 94.8% of Y. pestis strains were typical for these autonomous foci, and 5.2% of strains were altered in some properties. In terms of genotypic properties, 98.4% were typical, had standard chromosomal locus genes and 1.6% lacked the сaf1 gene (plasmid pFra). The majority of atypical Y. pestis strains were identified in the first subgroup. Analysis of the results showed that strains with atypical properties were 8.2 times more frequent in autonomous plague foci of the second subgroup.
Virulence of the plague pathogen is a polydeterminant trait that is encoded and controlled by a large number of genes localised on the chromosome and plasmids of the microbe. Determinants of plague microbe virulence include pigment-sorption ability, fraction 1 (FI), calcium ion dependence (Ca-), pesticinogenicity (Pst), VW antigen formation, mouse toxin formation. A total of 1220 serological reactions were performed in search of FI antigen, and 1198 strains had FI at concentrations ranging from 320 to 81920 m.c./ml. FI antigen was not detected in 22 strains from Pre-Balkhash and 1 strain from Muyun-Kum plague foci.
It is believed that in Y. pestis the pigment-sorption and calcium-dependence traits are closely related to the virulence of the microbe. The strains of the plague microbe were homogeneous regarding these traits. Their populations consisted mainly of calcium-dependent (97.8 ± 2.4%) and pigment-sorbing cells (95.4 ± 1.6%). The pigment-sorbing sign (Pgm-sign) on the Jackson-Burrows medium was studied in all studied strains of Y. pestis. According to the results, the number of Pgm+ cells was 94.7%, and the number of Pgm- cells was 5.3%. Pesticinogenic (Pst+) strains, as a rule, can liquefy fibrin and clot plasma; non-pesticinogenic (Pst-) strains lack this ability. Of all strains studied, 91.1% produced pesticin 1 but were not sensitive to it, whereas 6 strains of Y. pestis (0.9%) from the Pre-Balkhash plague focus did not produce pesticin 1.
The plague pathogen is a natural auxotroph, and most strains of the main subspecies require the presence of the basic amino acids’ methionine, phenylalanine and threonine to grow on artificial media. According to some reports, strains from some plague foci in Kazakhstan additionally needed cysteine, leucine, and arginine [20].
The amino acid requirements of the plague microbe were studied using a conventional method. The following environments were used to determine the need for growth factors: basic medium “A” – minimal medium without amino acids; medium “No. 4” – with amino acids phenylalanine, methionine and cysteine; medium “No. 6” – with phenylalanine, methionine, cysteine and threonine; medium “No. 7” – with phenylalanine, methionine, cysteine, threonine and arginine. According to the authors’ results, the studied strains (97%) require phenylalanine, methionine and cysteine. The first group were found dependent only on threonine – 0.65% of strains (Pre-Balkhash plague focus. In the same group, 2.45% of strains were arginine dependent: 1.78% of strains from Pre-Balkhash, 0.13% from North-Aral and 0.96% from Ili intermountain plague foci.
In the second group, 98.38% of plague strains were demanding phenylalanine, methionine and cysteine. Arginine-dependent strains were also detected: 1.02% of strains from the Muyun-Kum autonomous focus and 0.6% from the Tau-Kum autonomous focus. In the two analysed groups, strains with different amino acid requirements were found, regardless of epizootic manifestations and epidemic activity.
Thus, the results of laboratory studies showed that all strains of Y. pestis by phenotypic and molecular-genetic properties were typical for the Central-Asian desert region of the plague focus of Kazakhstan: and had the same biological and biochemical properties regardless of the place, season and source of isolation, except for 5.2% of strains phenotypic and 1.6% by genotypic properties.
Whole-genome sequencing and VNTR analysisIn 2022, DNA fragments of 32 Y. pestis strains were selected and isolated for whole-genome sequencing on the MiSeq platform using MiSeq Reagent Kit v3 reagents. DNA concentrations were measured by spectrophotometric and fluorometric methods using a NanoDrop1000 spectrophotometer and a Qubit fluorometer, respectively (Table 2).
Sequencing was performed with universal primers 8F (5'-AGAGAGTTTGATCCTGGCTCAG-3') and 806R (5'-GGACTACCAGGGTATCTAAT-3'). The sequences obtained were identical to the National Centre for Biotechnology Information Basic Local Alignment Search Tool database regarding the database “16S ribosomal RNA sequences (Bacteria and Archaea)”. The results of species identification of all samples were specific and identified as Y. pestis. The results of whole-genome sequencing were entered into a modular tool for combining the results of bioinformatic analysis of multiple samples into a single report of the MultiQC software. The MultiQC reporting tool analysed and displayed the results and statistics of the main console output data (Table 3).
The table of overall statistics shows the scores from the various instruments collected for each sample (sample example samples: L001_R2_001, 22.8%, 47%, 258 bp, 0.8; L001_R1_001, 24.4%, 47%, 262 bp, 1). Collecting data in a single report provides a quick and easy way to view key statistics. For instance, the genome of Y. pestis-IM-1 consisted of a single ring chromosome with a length of 4,567,859 base pairs with an average G+C content of 47%. Of this total, 209 were included in the final contig map. Across all samples, the total read length was 262 bp.
MultiQC scans the specified analysis directories for log files and quality control reports and generates a single summary report that visualises the results for all DNA samples of 32 Y. pestis strains, which are given in the first section “General Statistics”, where rows and columns with parameters are specified: sample name, % duplicates, % GC, read length and M/sec (Table 4).
In the MultQC programme, the main sections are distributed in tabs – FastQC. For the bioinformatics analysis, FastQC is presented according to the following indicators: number of sequences, sequence quality histograms, quality indicators by sequence, base sequence content, GC content for each sequence, by base N content, sequence length distribution, sequence duplication levels, over-represented sequences, adapter content and status checks. Examples of FastQC metrics are shown in Figure 3.
In the “Number of sequences” section, the sequence count for each sample was performed (the number of repeated reads is approximate). The number of reads ranged from 100k to 1400k, the uniqueness of the reads was in the range of 1,002,175 (74.5%) to 310,399 (90.6%), the maximum repeated reads were 32,078 (9.4%), and the percentage of reads was 100%. The average quality value for each base position in the reads is shown in the Sequence Quality Histograms section. The data in the “Sequence Quality Indicators” section shows the number of reads with average quality indicators, which showed whether a subset of read operations had low quality.
The proportion of each position for which each of the four normal DNA bases was called is located in the section “Base Sequence Content”, with the position indicated: -%T:-%C:-%A:-%G:. The average GC content of the reads, which indicates a random library with an approximately normal distribution of GC content, was reported in the section “GC content for each sequence”, in % GC. The percentage of base calls in each position was taken from the section “By base content N”, and the fragment size distributions (read lengths) were found in the section “Sequence length distribution”.
The relative level of duplication detected for each sample sequence and the number of overrepresented sequences detected in each library were obtained from the “Sequence Duplication Levels” and “Overrepresented Sequences” sections. The cumulative percentage of the fraction of the library that saw each of the adapter sequences at each position was reported in the “Adapter Content” section. The status of each FastQC section showing whether the results appear to be completely normal (green), slightly abnormal (orange), or very unusual (red) was provided in the “Status Checks” section.
Thus, the reports show the overall success of the analysis making it easy to identify abnormal samples and indicate the correctness of the whole-genome analysis. To extrapolate the order of the genes in the genome, the comparison of reads with the CO92 reference genome for all strains was analysed. It should be noted that as the field of next-generation sequencing develops, more and more bioinformatics tools are emerging that provide more and more detailed descriptions of the data.
In 2023, DNA fragments of 16 Y. pestis strains isolated only from desert plague foci of Kazakhstan were selected and isolated for full genome sequencing. Sequencing was performed on the MiniION platform “Mk1C MIN-101C” in Oxford Nanopore England. The study was conducted according to the generally accepted methodology. Evaluation of the obtained reads was carried out by FastQC and MultiQC programmes. The average length of the reads was in the range of 225-280. After analysing the quality of the raw data, the authors proceeded to the stage of filtering low-quality reads and trimming adaptor sequences using the Trimmomatic tool. The authors used tools such as SAMtools to evaluate the quality of the produced alignment. The authors analysed various parameters including average coverage, depth of coverage, base quality distribution and other metrics. This ensured that the alignment produced was correct and of high quality.
To assess the genetic relationships between the samples, a phylogenetic tree was constructed based on whole-genome sequencing data. The phylogenetic tree was constructed based on whole-genome sequencing data using the Maximum Likelihood method and MEGA11 software, as shown in Figure 4.
The phylogenetic tree of 32 Y. pestis strains obtained during the study allows us to draw the following key conclusions. According to the presented dendrogram, constructed based on genetic data analysis, the studied strains of Y. pestis are divided into three main clusters within the studied strains. Cluster “I” isolates belonging to the Medievalis biovar (2.MED1) constituted the main group: IM-1, IM-2, IM-3, IM-5, IM-6, KK-1, TK-1, TK-2 MK-1, MK-2, MK-2, PAK-1, PAK-2, PAK-4, PAK-5, PB-2, PB-3, PB-4, UE-1, UE-3, UE-4 (representatives of desert plague foci). Cluster “II” were represented by the following strains belonging to the Pestoides biovar (0.PE4a.c): TL-2, TL-3, TL-6, TL-7 (representatives of Talas highland plague foci). All other strains were included in Cluster “III” belonging to the Antiqua biovar, grouped into 2 branches – 0.ANT2b, 0.ANT3a.
Isolates of subcluster 0.ANT2b: SZ-12, SZ-13, SZ-16, and SZ-9 were representatives of the Sary-Djaz highland plague outbreak. Subcluster 0.ANT3a included one strain from the desert outbreak PB-1 (Pre-Balkhash) and three from the highland outbreak SZ-4, SZ-14, SZ-15 (Sary-Djaz). The detection of such a strain in the desert outbreak, which is typical of highland outbreaks, may have been carried by animals or through the water of rivers flowing from the Tian Shan Mountains, where the Sary-Djaz highland outbreak is located.
The phylogenetic tree obtained during the studies of 16 strains of Y. pestis from desert plague foci was used to draw the following key conclusions: According to the presented dendrogram constructed based on genetic data analysis, the studied strains of Y. pestis divided into four main clusters within the studied strains. Cluster І included all strains of Y. pseudotuberculosis, cluster II comprises the reference strain Pestoides F, cluster III was represented by the reference strains Y. pestis Nepal516 (branch 2. ANT1) and CO92 belonging to the Orientalis biovar (branch 1. ORI1), and cluster IV included the reference strain Y. pestis KIM10 and all the reference strains Y. pestis KIM10 and all 16 strains studied that belonged to the Medievalis biovar (branch 2. MED1).
All studied plague microbe isolates isolated in Ural-Embi, Pre-Aral-Karakum, Pre-Ustyurt, Pre-Balkhash, Ili intermountain, Kyzylkum, Betpak-Dala and Muyun-Kum autonomous foci of the Central-Asian desert region were included in cluster IV, grouped into three branches – IVa, IVb, IVc. Subcluster IVa included strains from Pre-Ustyurt and Ural-Embi plague foci. Subcluster IVb is divided into two branches, where 2 isolates from Ili intermountain foci constitute one grouping, and strains from Pre-Balkhash, Ural-Embi, and Pre-Ustyurt autonomous foci constitute another grouping. Subcluster IVc, containing three branches, where 2 isolates from Betpak-Dala, Muyun-Kum, and Pre-Aral-Karakum autonomous plague foci are grouped separately, is distinguished as a branch in the dendrogram.
The results of the study demonstrated the genetic similarity of all tested samples with the reference strain Y. pestis KIM10+, which belongs to the Medievalis biovar. pestis KIM10+, which belongs to the Medievalis biovar. These results confirm the specificity of the studies conducted and emphasise the importance of classification and monitoring within species of Y. pestis strains for a better understanding of the distribution and evolution of this pathogen.
In addition to the above-mentioned studies in 2023, to determine the productivity of the use of individual methods and to compile an algorithm for assessing the genetic diversity of natural isolates of Y. pestis of Kazakhstan, multilocus molecular DNA typing of 34 strains isolated in the period 1950-2022 using the MLVA method at 25 VNTR loci was carried out. The study was conducted according to the generally accepted methodology [17].
The obtained data were encoded in the form of a binary code matrix, where the resulting matrix was loaded into PAUP 4.0, which constructed a phylogenetic tree based on it using the UPGMA algorithm. The resulting tree was further optimised using FigTree v1.4.2.
According to the presented dendrogram, the studied Y. pestis and Y. pseudotuberculosis strains were divided into eight main clusters: cluster I included all Y. pseudotuberculosis strains, including the reference strain KZ_2841; cluster II was represented by the reference strain Y. pestis 790 (bv. Antiqua, 0. ANT3; clusters III, IV and V were composed of reference strains belonging to the Orientalis biovar (1. 1. pestis 790 (bv. Antiqua, 0. ANT3); clusters III, IV and V were composed of reference strains belonging to the Orientalis biovar (1. ORI1 and 1. ORI3); cluster VI was represented by reference strains KIM10 and PS1045 belonging to phylogroup 2. MED1 (bv. Medievalis), and all 34 isolates of Volga-Ural, Ural-Uilsky, Aryskum-Daryalyktakyr, Pre-Aral-Karakum, North Pre-Aral, Ili intermountain and Pre-Ustyurt autonomous foci of the Central Asian Desert Plague Foci of Kazakhstan were included here.
The study also determined that 34 studied isolates of Y. pestis of the VІ cluster were divided into three more subclusters in the hierarchical branch of the dendrogram (VII, VІII). At the same time, 20 isolates from the Aral Sea region were subdivided into eight genotypes located in clusters VІ and VII. 2 isolates from Volga-Ural and 1 isolate from Ural-Uilsky a.o. Constituted one genotype in cluster VІІ, 1 isolate from Pre-Ustyurt a.o. and 1 isolate from North Pre-Aral a.o. Constituted one genotype in cluster VII. 2 isolates from Pre-Ustyurt a.o., 1 isolate from Volga-Ural a.o. and 2 isolates from Pre-Aral region grouped into one genotype of cluster VII. 2 isolates from Volga-Ural a.o. and 3 isolates from Ili intermountain a.o. Formed one genotype of the VІII cluster.
Thus, the results of laboratory studies of Y. pestis strains of Kazakhstan were used to identify their species and subspecies position; to establish the presence of virulence genes and indicators of their polymorphism, the identity of the strain to a particular biological variant, belonging to a given plague focus, and the possibility to assess the presence of genetic links with other strains of Y. pestis. Such studies will improve the reliability, validity and quality of indicators, and increase the informativeness due to the variability of pheno- and genotypic properties of the studied strains.
Biodiversity analysis with a plague microbe strainMasgut Aikimbayev National Scientific Centre for Particularly Dangerous Infections researchers genotyped a total of 225 Y. pestis strains [20, 21] during the period 2007-2023, including DNA from 82 Y. pestis strains isolated from desert areas (Ural-Embi – 3, Pre-Ustyurt – 5, Ustyurt – 13, North Pre-Aral – 9, Aryskum-Daryalyktakyr– 12, Mangystau – 4, Pre-Aral-Karakum – 14, Kyzylkum – 33, Muyun-Kum – 21, Taukum – 7, Pre-Balkhash – 45, Betpak-Dala – 7, Pre-Аlakol – 11, Ili intermountain – 13), highlands (Sary-Djaz – 11 and Talas – 6) and Caspian Depression centres (Volga-Ural sandy – 4, Volga-Ural steppe – 5 and Ural- Uilsky steppe – 2).
As a result of a comprehensive analysis obtained in the course of laboratory experiments, the study identified 203 sequenced strains of Y. pestis of the phylogenetic branch of the biovar Medievalis (2.MED1 and 2.MED0), 12 sequenced strains of Y. pestis biovar Antiqua (0.ANT2b and 0.ANT3a), 6 sequenced strains of Y. pestis biovar Microtus/Antiqua 0.PE4 and 0.PE4a.c (Figure 5).
225 strains (str.) of Y. pestis submitted for analysis were predominantly isolated from rodents, including great gerbils and their ectoparasites, therefore: from Rhombomys opimus – 99 str., Marmota caudata – 6 str., Marmota baibacina – 4 str., Meriones libycus – 4 str., Meriones tamariscinus – 3 str., Mus musculus – 5 str., Meriones meridianus – 4 str., Spermophilus pygmaeus – 3 str., Spermophilopsis leptodactylus – 4 str., Citellus pygmaeus – 3 str., Allactaga sibirica – 1 str., from flea of species Xenopsylla gerbili – 13 str., Xenopsylla gerbili minax – 10 str., Xenopsylla skrjabini – 11 str., Ceratophyllus caspius – 1 str., Nosopsyllus laeviceps – 2 str., Xenopsylla conformis – 1 str., Coptopsylla lamellifer – 3 str., X. hirtipes – 2 str., Echidnophaga oschanini – 2 str., C. laeviceps – 1 str., Rhadinopsylla liventricosa – 1 str., fleas without definition – 15 str., red marmot flea – 4 str., ixodid ticks – 4 str., and the remaining 27 strains of Y. pestis were isolated from camel (7 str.) and from people (20 str.).
Notably, the isolated and studied strains from desert foci in 80-90% of cases were isolated from the main carrier (R. opimus) and their ectoparasites (fleas of the genus Xenopsylla). There is a significant seasonal interaction between them, which contributes to Y. pestis's persistence in natural plague foci. Due to ideal climatic conditions, flea numbers rise during warmer months, increasing the likelihood of transmission [26, 27]. Colder seasons, on the other hand, diminish flea activity and abundance, which lowers transmission yet permits the virus to remain dormant or low-activity in both hosts and vectors. Long-term persistence of the disease in enzootic cycles is ensured by this seasonal fluctuation, which produces a cyclical dynamic where plague bacteria live in flea populations and gerbil burrows during times of low transmission. For Y. pestis populations to remain in the environment over time, host and vector ecology must synchronise with the seasons.
Based on the obtained data on biodiversity and spatial and temporal characterisation of plague microbe strains circulating in natural foci of Kazakhstan and neighbouring countries, a geoinformation map was made using GIS technology tools (Figure 6).
Thus, the Central Asian desert plague focus in terms of area, epidemic manifestations in the past (before 2003) and epizootic activity currently occupies a leading position in comparison with the steppe and highland plague focuses of Kazakhstan. Within the groups of desert natural plague foci, the epizootic process during 2010-2023 was recorded virtually continuously, while in some autonomous foci, seasonality and long-term cyclicality of epizootic manifestations of plague among wild animals were clearly expressed.
The results of laboratory studies showed that all Y. pestis strains were typical for the Central Asian desert plague focus by phenotypic and molecular-genetic characteristics and belonged to the medieval biovar – Medievalis of the causative agent Y. pestis, except for single atypical variants by some biochemical properties. In order to improve sensitivity and specificity in plague surveillance, diagnostic techniques must be customised to identify a wider range of strain variants, as indicated by the observed genetic and phenotypic variation. Furthermore, by guiding risk assessments of virulence and transmission dynamics across various ecological zones, knowledge of strain diversity aids in the creation of focused preventative efforts. This information helps to increase epidemiological control and lower the risk of human epidemics by facilitating the development of more efficient monitoring techniques, vaccines, and antimicrobial treatment regimens.
DiscussionThe features of the functioning of the parasitic system of the plague natural foci of the Republic of Kazakhstan are studied in terms of the influence of the natural and human factors on the biodiversity of Y. pestis, which have been spreading over this territory for the past 30 years. The definition of genetic variability and features of epizootological differentiation, as well as the ecological situation in the regions, is determined by the microbiological aspects of the biocenotic structure of the natural foci.
At present, the pheno- and genotypic properties of the plague microbe, as well as other pathogens causing large outbreaks and mass epidemics among humans and animals are well enough studied. It is known that the genome of the plague pathogen consists of a chromosome of 4.65 million base pairs (bp) and three non-conjugative plasmids – pCad (70.3 thousand base pairs (bp)), pFra (96.2 bp) and pPst (9.6 bp). Of these, the calcium-dependent plasmid pCad was detected in cellular structure and in less pathogenic Yersinia such as Y. pseudotuberculosis and Y. enterocolitica cells, which was a genus-specific gene. The presence of this plasmid pCad is mandatory for the virulence of Y. pestis.
Two other plasmids, pFra and pPst (pPla), which are species-specific, are mandatory for diagnostic tests. The pFra plasmid encodes the synthesis of capsular antigen and mouse toxin, and the pPst plasmid responds to the production of bacteriocin pesticide and plasminogen activator. According to Byvalov et al. [28], even among isolates from the same natural focus, genetic and phenotypic variability of the plague microbe, including differences in the composition and structure of plasmids, is observed. For instance, the size of the pCad plasmid ranges from 65 to 75 bp, and that of the pFra plasmid from 60 to 80-90 bp.
As noted, the chromosome of Y. pestis chromosome contains a large number of pseudogenes and the structure of these genes can be disturbed by introductions of various IS elements, deletions, insertions, and point mutations. It was also determined by Sarfraz et al. that the genome of Y. pestis genome contains regions with variable tandem repeats of different sequences [29]. The absence or presence of the above-mentioned characteristics of the genome determines the phenotypic and genetic biodiversity of Y. pestis strains, including during passporting of natural plague foci and possibly for obtaining information on the origin of the source of infection [30].
Phenotypic features interacting with the organisation of Y. pestis and Y. pseudotuberculosis genomes studied by Andrades Valtueña et al. [31], are one of the factors that ensure the process of infection with the plague microbe. These are the main plasmids, which provide block formation in the flea gizzard, acquired as a result of the interaction of genomes: pPst and pFra, as well as expression of hmsT gene occurring inside the cell, regardless of external circumstances – a part of the hms operon. As a result of organisation, the genomes Y. pestis and Y. pseudotuberculosis lose the ability to synthesise lipopolysaccharide O-side chains, the synthesis of YadA adhesin and urease, aspartase, Inv and Ail invasins (insert IS-elements), some amino acids, enzymes, and the loss of mobility have also been lost. According to Andrades Valtueña et al., Y. pseudotuberculosis is a likely precursor of Y. pestis. The indicator of the nucleotide sequence of the genes’ accumulation of the O-antigen is 98.9% homologous to the similar hidden accumulation of genes of the plague microbe. In the process of chromosomal rearrangements as a result of the division of some chromosomes and genetic mutations, 5 “biosynthetic” genes out of 17 identified ones in Y. pseudotuberculosis are inactivated in the genome.
An analysis of a study by Hussain et al. [32] in search for the reasons for genetic structure in the biosynthesis of lipopolysaccharides in Y. pestis, Y. pseudotuberculosis and Y. enterocolitica concluded that the clone of the plague microbe from Y. pseudotuberculosis had evolved even before the first plague outbreak more than 1500 years ago. However, Hussain et al. did not recognise several properties as absolute ones for intrawater separation of the plague microbe. One or another factor can be either vividly expressed or absent. In the process of adaptation to a certain type of carrier during infection of rodents with Y. pestis strains from other carriers, it has been shown a sign of variability in the phenotypic properties of the plague microbe on a micro-evolutionary scale, modelled in the experiments by Trzilova & Tamayo [33]. As a result of 10-15 subcutaneous passages of Y. pestis strains, the body of an unusual host demonstrated signs of variability specific to this carrier.
The issues of detection of atypical and low-virulence strains in natural plague foci are relevant and require constant study of freshly isolated strains. It is generally accepted that atypical variants and low-virulence strains can cause prolonged forms of the infectious process [34], which may affect the epidemic and the duration of the epizootic process in nature, and possibly the persistence of the plague pathogen and the direct impact on the inter-epizootic period. Therefore, constant microbiological monitoring of natural plague foci is necessary to be able to extrapolate the order of genes in the genome and to analyse the comparison of reads against the data of reference strains. It should be noted that as the field of next-generation sequencing develops, more and more bioinformatics tools are emerging that provide more detailed descriptions of the data, to compile a genebank and gene biorepository [30].
The use of classical methods of studying phenotypic properties of infectious agents, based on classical methods have not lost their importance today, but at the same time, the current successes of modern genetics and molecular biology, up bring the issues and tasks of pheno- and genodiagnostics of Y. pestis to the highest stable level, based on molecular biology, genetic engineering and bioinformatics. Additionally, the impact of climatic changes and human activity on the distribution and evolution of the plague microbe in Kazakhstan are notable. Rising temperatures, changes in precipitation patterns and other climatic factors can affect the populations of rodents, the main reservoirs of infection, as well as the numbers and activity of vectors such as fleas [35]. Anthropogenic factors, including urbanisation, agricultural activities and landscape change, can also create conditions for the emergence of new foci of infection or the amplification of existing ones [36-38]. Modern molecular epidemiology techniques, including full genome sequencing and analysis of multi-locus variegated tandem repeats, provide valuable data for tracing the transmission and spread of Y. pestis. These methods can identify genetic markers that characterise specific populations of the pathogen and correlate them with geographical and environmental data. This approach facilitates a better understanding of epizootic dynamics and the development of effective control and prevention strategies.
The research conducted in the Republic of Kazakhstan is important not only for the national but also for the global epidemiological surveillance system [39]. Given the strategic location of the country and the presence of cross-border animal migration flows, understanding the peculiarities of plague spread in this region helps to prevent possible international outbreaks of the disease.
It is also important to pay attention to the problem of antibiotic resistance in Y. pestis. Although antibiotic resistance among plague strains is currently rare, the emergence of such strains can have serious consequences for public health. Therefore, monitoring the susceptibility of Y. pestis to antimicrobial agents and studying the mechanisms of potential resistance is an integral part of epidemiological surveillance. In light of the possible use of Y. pestis as a biological weapon, research into the genetics and molecular biology of the plague microbe is of particular relevance. A deep understanding of the genetic mechanisms of virulence and pathogenicity of the pathogen allows the development of effective measures to counter bioterrorism and strengthen national biosecurity [40, 41].
In conclusion, the integration of classical microbiological methods with modern molecular genetics and bioinformatics approaches obtained the most complete overview of Y. pestis biology, its variability and epidemiological significance. This, in turn, contributes to the development of effective strategies for the prevention and control of the disease, strengthening the epidemiological surveillance system and ensuring biological safety both in the Republic of Kazakhstan and globally.
ConclusionsThe results of the analysis and epizootological monitoring demonstrated that the natural plague foci of Kazakhstan are extensive in their area, have a high epidemic and epizootic potential, remain active and pose a real threat of human infection. During 2010-2023, 1,220 strains of Yersinia pestis were analysed, with 94.8% showing typical phenotypic properties and 5.2% displaying altered characteristics; genotypically, 98.4% of strains were typical while 1.6% lacked the caf1 gene. In the conditions of the modern world, characterised by climate change and anthropogenic impact, it is necessary to apply new strategies and tactics of plague monitoring, including modern methods of molecular genetic analysis and the use of geoinformation systems to track the spread of the pathogen. An important stage of this work was the creation of a DNA biorepository of circulating strains of Y. pestis and the passportisation of natural plague foci at the level of primary landscape-epizootological areas. This will make it possible to consider the results of surveys in a differentiated manner, to ensure uniformity of approaches to the control of territories and to increase the efficiency of epidemiological surveillance. Thanks to continuous epizootological monitoring and preventive measures, including disinsection, deratisation and sanitary and educational work, there has been no human morbidity in Kazakhstan since 2003. This confirms the effectiveness of the measures taken and emphasises the need to continue and improve them.
The created electronic database “Biorepository of genetic characteristics of Y. pestis strains of natural plague foci of Kazakhstan” will become substantial for analysing genetic biodiversity, studying phylogenetic relationships, and revealing patterns of evolution and distribution of the pathogen. This biorepository currently includes molecular genetic data from over 300 isolates, including full genome sequences of 48 strains and multilocus VNTR profiles of 34 strains, enabling detailed phylogenetic clustering into at least eight main clusters and multiple subclusters. It will be used to identify and deposit strains of unknown origin isolated during plague outbreaks or acts of bioterrorism. Continuous updating of the database will provide access to up-to-date information on specific strains for research and development, the development of new diagnostic methods, and the creation of effective means of prevention and treatment. This will create conditions for the development of new methods of plague control and deepen the understanding of the epidemiology and pathogenesis of the infection.
Continued research in the field of genetic biodiversity of Y. pestis and monitoring of natural plague foci will make it possible to improve the system of epidemiological surveillance, timely detect changes in the circulation of the pathogen and take adequate measures to prevent possible epidemics among the population. The study showed that plague foci in Kazakhstan cover approximately 1,117,000 km², representing about 41% of the country’s territory, with an increase of nearly 80,000 km² (9.98%) in plague foci area over 1990-2020, driven by climatic and anthropogenic factors. The genetic monitoring identified persistent circulation of Medievalis biovar strains in desert foci comprising over 80% of isolates, and the detection of atypical strains at frequencies up to 5.2% in some regions, indicating ongoing microevolution and epidemiological complexity. The study significantly contributed to the biological security of the country and the health of its citizens. Thus, the use of modern research methods and the creation of a biorepository of Y. pestis strains are important steps towards improving the plague monitoring system in Kazakhstan. This will improve the effectiveness of preventive measures, increase knowledge about the biology and evolution of this dangerous pathogen and, ultimately, contribute to the protection of public health and sustainable development of the country.
Among the study's limitations is the small number of Yersinia pestis strains with whole genome sequencing, which may restrict the scope of the genetic diversity analysis. Recent pathogen alterations might not be captured by the temporal range of samples, and emerging technologies could improve the phenotypic and genotypic techniques now employed. Predictive capacity was limited since environmental elements were taken into account but not quantitatively modelled. Furthermore, the representativeness of the data and the generalisability of the findings may be impacted by unequal geographic sampling.
NotesConflict of interest
The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.
Funding
The research was carried out as part of the project of the Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan on the topic “Study of antibiotic resistance genes of plague and cholera pathogens, design of PCR test system”, the project IRN – AP19679355, funding source – the Committee of Science of the Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan.
CRediT author statement
BA: Conceptualization, Investigation, Formal analysis, Data curation, writing original draft, Writing, review and editing, and statistical analysis; AZ: Conceptualization, Supervision, review & editing; RM: Conceptualization, Supervision, review & editing; DO: Conceptualization, Data curation, review & editing; ZZ: Conceptualization, review & editing.
References1. World Health Organization. Plague. [cited June 6, 2025]. Available from: https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/plague.
2. Kirimbayeva Z, Abutalip A, Mussayeva A, Kuzembekova G, Yegorova N. Epizootological monitoring of some bacterial infectious diseases of animals on the territory of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Comp Immunol Microbiol Infect Dis 2023;102: 102061 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cimid.2023.102061.
3. Murabildayeva R, Bimendiyeva L, Kondybayeva S, Yermekova Zhanna. Climate change and agricultural productivity: Economic implications for food security. Scientific Horizons 2024;27(12):168-179 https://doi.org/10.48077/scihor12.2024.168.
4. Meka-Mechenko TV, Erubaev TK, Begimbaeva EZ, Kovaleva GG, Abdel ZZ, Sutyagin VV, et al. Multilevel system of studying plague microbe strains proprties in the Republic of Kazakhstan. Problems of particularly dangerous infections 2022;4: 23-28 https://doi.org/10.21055/0370-1069-2022-4-23-28 [Russian].
5. Keller M, Spyrou MA, Scheib CL, Neumann GU, Kröpelin A, Haas-Gebhard B, et al. Ancient Yersinia pestis genomes from across Western Europe reveal early diversification during the First Pandemic (541-750). Proc Natl Acad Sci U. S. A. 2019;116(25):12363-12372 https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1820447116.
6. Venugopal G, Pechous RD. Yersinia pestis and pneumonic plague: Insight into how a lethal pathogen interfaces with innate immune populations in the lung to cause severe disease. Cell Immunol 2024;403-404: 104856 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cellimm.2024.104856.
7. Demeure C, Dussurget O, Fiol GM, Le Guern A, Savin C, Pizarro-Cerdá J. Yersinia pestis and plague: An updated view on evolution, virulence determinants, immune subversion, vaccination, and diagnostics. Genes Immun 2019;20(5):357-370 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41435-019-0065-0.
8. Dzhaparova AK, Eroshenko GA, Nikiforov KA, Kukleva LM, Al’khova ZV, Berdiev SK, et al. Characteristics and philogenetic analysis of Yersinia pseudotuberculosis strains from the Sarydzhaz high-mountain focus in the Tien-Shan. Problems of particularly dangerous infections 2021;2: 87-93 https://doi.org/10.21055/0370-1069-2021-2-87-93 [Russian].
9. Sariyeva G, Bazarkanova G, Maimulov R, Abdikarimov S, Kurmanov B, Abdirassilova A, et al. Marmots and Yersinia pestis strains in two plague endemic areas of Tien Shan mountains. Front Vet Sci 2019;6: 207 https://doi.org/10.3389/fvets.2019.00207.
10. Abutalip A, Suchshikh V, Aitzhanov B, Ospanov Y, Kanatov B. Current state of animal anthrax problems in the Republic of Kazakhstan and ways to solve it. Int J Vet Sci 2024;13(6):922-930 https://doi.org/10.47278/journal.ijvs/2024.198.
11. Yermukhanova LS, Urazaeva S, Artukbaeva M, Azhenova K, Almakhanova M, Zhaubassova A, et al. Determination of the air pollution index of atmospheric air in Aktobe. Ann Trop Med Public Health 2017;10(3):664-666 https://doi.org/10.4103/ATMPH.ATMPH_209_17.
12. Abdel ZZ, Erubaev TK, Tokmurzieva GZ, Aimakhanov BK, Dalibaev ZS, Musagalieva RS, et al. Demarcation of the boundaries of the Central Asian desert natural focus of plague of Kazakhstan and monitoring the areal of the main carrier Rhombomys opimus. Problems of Particularly Dangerous Infections 2021;2: 71-78 https://doi.org/10.21055/0370-1069-2021-2-71-78 [Russian].
13. Balykova AN, Katyshev AD, Eroshenko GA, Kukleva LM, Dzhaparova AK, Naryshkina EA, et al. Whole genome sequences of Yersinia pestis strains of ancient phylogenetic branch 0.ANT5 isolated in the 21st century in the Tien-Shan in Kyrgyzstan. Microbiol Resour Announc 2024;13(10):e0046924. https://doi.org/10.1128/mra.00469-24.
14. Rametov NM, Steiner M, Bizhanova NA, Abdel ZZ, Yessimseit DT, Abdeliyev BZ, et al. Mapping plague risk using Super Species Distribution Models and forecasts for rodents in the Zhambyl region, Kazakhstan. Geohealth 2023;7(11):e2023GH000853. https://doi.org/10.1029/2023GH000853.
15. Suchshikh V, Karimov A, Yussupov M, Aitzhanov B, Abutalip A, Mussayeva A, et al. Effectiveness of different means of disinfection against soil foci of anthrax (Bacillus anthracis) burials at a depth of up to 3.5 m: an experimental study. Caspian Journal of Environmental Sciences 2023;21(4):893-902 https://doi.org/10.22124/cjes.2023.7147.
16. Mussayeva A, Yegorova N, Abutalip A, Aitzhanov B, Suchshikh V. Anaerobic enterotoxaemia and sheep Bradsot: Clostridiosis. Int J Vet Sci 2024;13(6):996-1001 https://doi.org/10.47278/journal.ijvs/2024.190.
17. World Health Organization (WHO). Laboratory biosafety manual. [cited June 6, 2025]. Available from: https://iris.who.int/handle/10665/365602 [Russian].
18. Resolution of the Ministry of Health of the Republic of Kazakhstan. No. 8 “On Making Amendments and Additions to the Resolution of the Chief State Sanitary Doctor of Kostanay Region No. 5”. [cited June 6, 2025]. Available from: https://www.gov.kz/memleket/entities/departament-kkbtu-kostanay/documents/details/138918?lang=ru [Russian].
19. Atshabar B, Nurtazhin ST, Shevtsov A, Ramankulov EM, Sayakova Z, Rysbekova A, et al. Populations of the major carrier Rhombomys opimus, vectors of Xenopsylla fleas and the causative agent of Yersinia pestis in the Central Asian desert natural focus of plague. Bulletin of the National Academy of Sciences of the Republic of Kazakhstan 2021;1(389):26-34 https://doi.org/10.32014/2021.2518-1467.4.
20. Meka-Mechenko TV, Izbanova UA, Abdel ZZ, Nakisbekov NO, Lukhnova LY, Baitursyn B, et al. Genotypic properties of collection plague microbes strains from the natural plague foci of Kazakhstan. Acta Biomed Sci 2022;7(6):111-118 https://doi.org/10.29413/ABS.2022-7.6.11 [Russian].
21. Abdel Z, Abdeliyev B, Yessimseit D, Begimbayeva E, Mussagalieva R. Natural foci of plague in Kazakhstan in the space-time continuum. Comp Immunol Microbiol Infect Dis 2023;100: 102025 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cimid.2023.102025.
22. Sagiyev Z, Berdibekov A, Bolger T, Merekenova A, Ashirova S, Nurgozhin Z, et al. Human response to live plague vaccine EV, Almaty region, Kazakhstan, 2014-2015. PLoS One 2019;14(6):e0218366. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0218366.
23. Pauling CD, Beerntsen BT, Song Q, Anderson DM. Transovarial transmission of Yersinia pestis in its flea vector Xenopsylla cheopis. Nat Commun 2024;15(1):7266 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-024-51668-0.
24. Nurgazy B, Yerezhepova N, Seilgazina S, Gabit G, Bupebayeva L, Bastaubaev AK. Livestock development in Kazakhstan: Results of meat productivity from steers of different genotypes (Research Base LLP «Agrofirm Dinara-Ranch»). Espacios 2019;40(42):1-5.
25. Shuvar I, Korpita H, Balkovskyi V, Shuvar A, Kropyvnytskyi R. Asclepias syriaca l. is a threat to biodiversity and agriculture of Ukraine. BIO Web Conf 2021;36: 07010 https://doi.org/10.1051/bioconf/20213607010.
26. Yespembetov BA, Syrym NS, Syzdykov MS, Kuznetsov AN, Koshemetov ZK, Mussayeva AK, et al. Impact of geographical factors on the spread of animal brucellosis in the Republic of Kazakhstan. Comp Immunol Microbiol Infect Dis 2019;67: 101349 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cimid.2019.101349.
27. Zhusupov A, Aldayarov N, Irgashev A, Nurgaziev R, Kuban A. A sporadic case of small ruminant plague in sheep: morphological and functional manifestation of cellular and humoral immunodeficiency. Scientific Horizons 2024;27(4):22-34 https://doi.org/10.48077/scihor4.2024.22.
28. Byvalov AA, Dudina LG, Kravchenko TB, Ivanov SA, Konyshev IV, Morozova NA, et al. The role of Yersinia pestis antigens in the reception of plague diagnostic bacteriophage L-413C. Appl Biochem Microbiol 2024;60(4):740-748 https://doi.org/10.1134/S0003683824604438.
29. Sarfraz A, Qurrat-Ul-Ain Fatima S, Shehroz M, Ahmad I, Zaman A, Nishan U, et al. Decrypting the multi-genome data for chimeric vaccine designing against the antibiotic resistant Yersinia pestis. Int Immunopharmacol 2024;132: 111952 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.intimp.2024.111952.
30. Nistane NT, Kale MB, Das RJ, Umare MD, Umekar MJ, Hemke AT, et al. Herbal remedies: An emerging alternative for the treatment of pandemic diseases. Current Traditional Medicine 2024;10(6):e030823219384. http://doi.org/10.2174/2215083810666230803101424.
31. Valtueña AA, Neumann GU, Spyrou MA, Musralina L, Aron F, Beisenov A, et al. Stone Age Yersinia pestis genomes shed light on the early evolution, diversity, and ecology of plague. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 2022;119(17):e2116722119. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2116722119.
32. Hussain T, Singh S, Danish M, Pervez R, Hussain K, Husain R. Natural metabolites: An eco-friendly approach to manage plant diseases and for better agriculture farming. In: Singh J, Yadav AN, editors. Natural bioactive products in sustainable agriculture. Springer; 2020. 1-13.
33. Trzilova D, Tamayo R. Site-specific recombination-how simple DNA inversions produce complex phenotypic heterogeneity in bacterial populations. Trends Genet 2021;37(1):59-72 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tig.2020.09.004.
34. Ushkarenko V, Chaban V, Kyrychenko K, Sokol A. Conditions for the formation of water quality with the biological cleaning method. Biological Systems: Theory and Innovation 2024;15(2):41-50 https://doi.org/10.31548/biologiya15(2).2024.004 [Russian].
35. Zhang L, Wang Z, Chang N, Shang M, Wei X, Li K, et al. Relationship between climatic factors and the flea index of two plague hosts in Xilingol League, Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region. Biosaf Health 2024;6(4):244-250 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bsheal.2024.07.004.
36. Abutalip A, Bizhanov A, Matikhan N, Karabassova A, Orynbayeva B. Regional epidemiology of brucellosis infection in modern conditions of animal husbandry technology in Kazakhstan (by the degree of spread and incidence). Scientific Horizons 2024;27(5):20-31 https://doi.org/10.48077/scihor5.2024.20.
37. Danilenko I, Gorban O, de Oliveira Pedro PMCZ, Viegas J, Shapovalova O, Akhkozov L, et al. Photocatalytic composite nanomaterial and engineering solution for inactivation of airborne bacteria. Top Catal 2021;64(13-16):772-779 https://doi.org/10.1007/s11244-020-01291-2.
38. Ruban S, Danshyn V, Pryima S, Sorak D. Meat cattle breeding in Ukraine (climate impact, breeding features, efficiency improvement strategies). Animal Science and Food Technology 2024;15(3):72-86 https://doi.org/10.31548/animal.3.2024.72.
39. Begon M, Davis S, Laudisoit A, Leirs H, Reijniers J. Sylvatic plague in Central Asia: A case study of abundance thresholds. In: Wilson K, Fenton A, Tompkins D, editors. Wildlife disease ecology: Linking theory to data and application. Cambridge University Press; 2019. 623-643.
40. Turmagambetova AS, Alexyuk MS, Bogoyavlenskiy AP, Linster M, Alexyuk PG, Zaitceva IA, et al. Monitoring of Newcastle disease virus in environmental samples. Arch Virol 2017;162(9):2843-2846 https://doi.org/10.1007/s00705-017-3433-y.
41. Korotetsky IS, Bogoyavlensky AP, Prilipov AG, Usachev EV, Usacheva OV, Turmagambetova AS, et al. Molecular genetic characteristics of the Newcastle disease virus velogenic strains isolated in Russia, Ukraine, Kazakhstan, and Kirghizia. Vopr Virusol 2010;55(4):29-32 [Russian].
Figure 2.Epizootological indicators of places of isolation of Y. pestis strains from rodents and their ectoparasites and detection of seropositive animals with antibodies to F1 plague microbe in plague foci of Kazakhstan in 2010-2023. Figure 3.FastQC tabs of the results of whole-genome sequencing of 32 Y. pestis strains: (a) sequence count for each sample; (b) GC content for each sample sequence; (c) adapter and sequence status check content; (d) average quality value for each base position in the sample sequence reads. Figure 4.Phylogenetic parameters (tree and dendrogram) of whole-genome sequencing and DNA genotyping of 82 Y. pestis strains circulating in natural foci of Kazakhstan: (a) tree of 32 isolates; (b) tree of 16 isolates; (c) dendrogram of 34 isolates; (d) tree of 34 isolates. Figure 5.Results of laboratory studies to determine the molecular-genetic properties of the plague microbe circulating in the Central Asian desert and Tien Shan high-mountain natural plague foci of Kazakhstan. Figure 6.Location of the sequenced strains from natural plague foci of Kazakhstan and species identified in the transboundary zones of the republic. Table 1.Results of a study of plague microbe strains isolated from desert plague foci in Kazakhstan in 2010-2023, in %.. Table 2.Results of DNA concentration measurements of 32 Y. pestis strains. Table 3.Results of whole-genome sequencing of DNA samples of 32 Y. pestis strains on the MiSeq platform. Table 4.General statistics of a modular tool for combining the results of bioinformatic analysis of multiple samples. |
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||